User:維基小霸王/Records

下面,我对中文维基百科的部分用户作为进行一个记录。

  • 中文维基百科的法轮功类条目禁止中国大陆参考资料,只能加入非中国、非法轮功的“第三方”资料,造成实质上以西方媒体来源为主,有的来源的作者没准就是信仰者。如果尝试加入,支持法轮功的用户(长期活跃的是User:Marvin_2009User:Wetrace)会进行回退[1][2]。给出的理由是:中国是镇压一方,媒体受中国控制,不属于“第三方可靠来源”。同时,这些用户认为,日本镇压的邪教、美国镇压的本拉登却可以使用相应国家媒体[3]。很多西方人把中国看作竞争对手(如[4]),因此西方媒体并非绝对的第三方。法轮功支持者,甚至是资深管理员对此找各种理由进行辩解[5]。不少资深用户、管理员对法轮功类条目的偏见无动于衷。
  • Chinese mainland citations are banned in Falun Gong-related articles on Chinese Wikipedia. Only "third party source", (i.e. non-China and non-Falun Gong sources) are allowed, which leads to the articles are mainly based no western sources, including those might be written by believers. If one tries to add any, Falun Gong supporters (User:Marvin_2009 and User:Wetrace are long-term active users of this kind) would revert[6][7]. The reason they gives is: China is the suppressor and Chinese media are controlled by China, therefore they are not reliable third party sources. However, these users urges for articles about a cult suppressed by Japan and Bin Laden's group is suppressed by the United States, media in the suppressor countries can be referenced[8]. Many in the west see China as a rival (e.g., [9]) and hence their media are not absolutely "third party" to China. Falun Gong supporters and even a senior admin defends the western media[10]. Many senior users and admins do nothing about the biased Fa Lungong-related articles.